The tin ceiling in the lobby at 400 N. 2nd Ave. made it through. So did the brick walls and the original chandeliers. When The Alpena News toured the building in June, the bathrooms had been renovated and a bar was planned for reinstallation. Upstairs, the apartments still had their original wooden doors, skylights, wainscoting and hardwood floors. The theatre scheduled "Autumn in New York," an evening of Frank Sinatra-style music from Mark Francis, for Oct. 24 and billed it as the first event in the newly renovated building.
That is a long way from where Thunder Bay Theatre was six years ago. The building itself is close to done. What still stands between the theatre and its first real production is mostly equipment you can't see from the sidewalk, plus a fundraising deadline of Nov. 14.
Two Fires, Three Years Apart
The six-year pause wasn't a single disaster. It was two, and the second hit while the recovery from the first was already underway.
- July 21, 2020. A fire at the John A. Lau Saloon next door started in a welding accident and destroyed the saloon, according to WBKB. The flames never reached the theatre, but water and smoke did serious damage inside.
- Sept. 5, 2023. Renovation work on the building began.
- Dec. 3, 2023. A fire broke out in the theatre's own rear warehouse. The theatre says the investigation was inconclusive and that old wiring was considered the likely cause. WCMU reported that the fire destroyed stored props, sets, furniture and backstage space, and that first responders found no malicious intent. The Alpena News called it the second fire-damage incident at the theatre in three years.
The second fire explains much of what's left on the to-do list now. Lighting and sound gear damaged in both fires has to be replaced before anyone can stage a show, and that is a separate job from restoring walls and roofs.
What $2 Million Already Bought
The theatre describes the project as a $2 million restoration of its 1903 building. It was paid for with support from the Michigan Economic Development Corporation, the State Historic Preservation Office, the Besser Foundation, the Michigan Arts & Culture Council, the First Federal Legacy Foundation and individual donors who have given since the 2020 fire.
According to the theatre's campaign page, that money has paid for:
- Restored historic facades
- All-new windows
- A new HVAC system
- A replaced roof
- A near-complete restoration of the lobby, the upstairs staff apartments and a new backstage area
The auditorium has 140 seats. The rear of the building now holds space for set design, dressing rooms and a green room, so the backstage lost in the 2023 fire has been rebuilt as part of the main project. When The Alpena News visited in June, a side mural and fresh paint on the facade lettering were still in the planning stage. The apartments upstairs are meant for theatre employees. That matters for a professional company that has to bring actors and staff to Alpena.
So the expensive, slow work is behind it. The structure, the systems and the historic finishes are done.
The Shopping List Between Here and Opening Night
What remains is short and specific. The MEDC's Sept. 16 announcement and the theatre's own campaign page list the same items:
- New stage lights for the auditorium
- A lighting grid and rigging system
- New speakers, a compatible sound board and wireless mics
- A new assisted listening system
- Furniture for the lobby, so the room can host year-round gatherings, public events and arts programs
The stage lights, rigging and sound board are what a musical or drama needs to go up in the auditorium. The assisted listening system decides whether audience members who rely on that kind of support can follow a show from those 140 seats. And the lobby furniture is what lets the front of the building work as a public room on nights with no performance.
Board president Anne Gentry put it directly in the MEDC release:
"We're incredibly close to reopening our doors, but we need the community's help to get to opening night. Before we can reopen, we need to purchase a new lighting and sound system for the auditorium, along with furniture for our lobby."
How the Match Works, and Where It Stood on Oct. 21
The money for that list is being raised through a crowdfunding campaign at patronicity.com/tbayt, which launched Sept. 15. It runs under the MEDC's Public Spaces Community Places program, a partnership between the MEDC, the Michigan Municipal League and Patronicity. If the campaign reaches $50,000 by Nov. 14, the MEDC adds a matching $50,000.
| As of Oct. 21, 2026 | |
|---|---|
| Campaign goal | $50,000 |
| Raised | $36,808, or 74% |
| Patrons | 93 |
| Still needed | $13,192 |
| Deadline | Nov. 14, 2026, 11:30 p.m. |
| State match if goal is met | $50,000 |
These numbers will have moved by the time you read this, so check the campaign page for the live total. Even so, the Oct. 21 snapshot shows the scale of what's left. At that point the 93 patrons had given an average of just under $400 each. At that pace, roughly three dozen more gifts would close the gap. Against a $2 million restoration, $13,192 is a small figure. But because the match only kicks in at the goal, that last stretch controls $63,192 in total: the remaining gifts plus the state's $50,000.
The momentum has been steady. In its Sept. 29 update, the campaign reported being at "just about half" of its goal after the second week, and it had climbed to 74% three weeks later. Statewide, the program has a strong track record. The MEDC says that as of Aug. 18, 2026, communities had reached their goals and earned matching funds 97% of the time, across 450 successful projects.
The Patronicity page lists Thunder Bay Theatre, Inc. as a registered 501(c)(3) and says contributions may be tax-deductible. That's general information, not tax advice, so check with your own tax professional about your situation. To give by cash or check instead of online, the theatre asks donors to call or text 989-464-9939, or to mail checks to Thunder Bay Theatre, PO Box 314, Alpena, MI 49707.
What the Calendar Looks Like After Nov. 14
The deadline lands on a busy downtown day. Saturday, Nov. 14 is also downtown Alpena's Holiday Kick-Off, which runs 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. as local businesses decorate their storefronts and open the holiday shopping season. Later that month, the Bolenz Jewelry Holiday Parade steps off Friday, Nov. 27 at 5:30 p.m. Its route runs along Chisholm Street, Second Avenue and Water Street, ending behind City Hall.
For the theatre itself, the timeline stretches into next year. In a Sept. 25 column in The Alpena News, Anne Gentry wrote that the theatre is planning a grand reopening in spring 2027, with several smaller events this fall and winter. She also recalled that the fire at John A. Lau is what closed the theatre in the first place. In June, The Alpena News reported that the board plans to hire staff in winter 2027 and stage its first production that spring, with more shows to follow in summer and fall. The planned mix includes children's productions, Broadway musicals, dramas and one-off concerts.
No show titles or opening-night date have been announced yet. Right now, the date that sets the schedule is Nov. 14, because the lights, speakers and rigging bought with the match are what the spring production will be staged on.
A working stage at 400 N. 2nd Ave. would bring back what the Michigan Municipal League calls the region's only year-round professional theater. If you have questions about downtown Alpena or anywhere else in our corner of northeastern Michigan, the team at Hillman Real Estate is always happy to talk about what's changing around here. Get in touch.